The brass key fitted perfectly.
She turned it.
The lock clicked.
The door opened.
Inside, dust covered the furniture.
A telescope stood near the window. A leather chair faced the city. Several framed photographs hung on the walls, their glass surfaces clouded with age.
Rosa stepped inside.
The room smelled of old wood and cold metal.
She switched on the lights.
At first, everything appeared ordinary.
Then she noticed the floor.
One section of the wooden boards near the telescope was slightly darker than the rest.
She knelt.
There were scratches around the edges.
Someone had opened it recently.
Rosa searched the room until she found a narrow metal tool inside a drawer.
She worked it beneath the wooden panel.
The board lifted.
Beneath it was a small compartment.
Inside lay a black envelope.
Her hands trembled as she opened it.
There were three things inside.
A photograph.
A folded letter.
And a hotel access card.
Rosa picked up the photograph first.
It showed Daniel Hart standing beside a young woman.
Isabelle.
But the photograph was dated twenty-two years earlier.
Isabelle looked no older than seven.
She was holding Daniel's hand.
And standing behind them was Rosa.
A younger Rosa, wearing the same small gold cross she still wore around her neck.
Rosa stared at the image.
She remembered that day.
It had been a summer afternoon.
Daniel had taken Isabelle to the rooftop garden to show her the telescope.
Rosa had brought lemonade.
But she did not remember the fourth person in the photograph.
A little girl standing beside Daniel.
The girl had the same green eyes as Isabelle.
The same dark hair.
The same face.
Rosa turned the photograph over.
A message had been written on the back.
THE FIRST GIRL NEVER LEFT.
Rosa felt her stomach tighten.
She unfolded the letter.
The handwriting was Daniel's.
Rosa,
If you are reading this, then the family has reached the point I spent years trying to prevent.
Evelyn will tell you that Isabelle is dead. Nate will tell you that the body has been identified. The police will tell you that the evidence is clear.
Do not believe them.
The girl who fell tonight was not Isabelle.
And the girl who remains in this building is not the person you think she is.
Rosa stopped reading.
Her eyes moved to the next paragraph.
There are two daughters in this family. One was born to be loved. The other was born to replace her.
I tried to protect them both.
I failed.
If you want to know which girl is alive, look beneath the observatory floor.
Rosa looked down.
She had already opened the compartment.
There was nothing else inside.
Then she noticed a small metal ring attached to the bottom of the compartment.
She pulled it.
A section of the floor shifted.
A narrow staircase appeared beneath the wooden boards.
Rosa stared into the darkness.
She could hear something.
A faint tapping.
Three knocks.
A pause.
Two more.
Her breath caught.
“Miss Isabelle?”
No answer.
Then a girl's voice came from below.
“Rosa?”
The older woman covered her mouth.
“Is that you?”
A pause.
Then:
“Please don't let them take me again.”
Rosa leaned toward the opening.
“Where are you?”
“Down here.”
“Are you hurt?”
The girl hesitated.
Then whispered:
“Not yet.”
Rosa began descending.
The girl beneath the floor
The staircase ended in a narrow corridor.
There was no electricity, only a small emergency light fixed to the wall.
At the end stood a metal door.
Rosa approached.
A small rectangular window had been cut into it.
She looked inside.
A young woman sat on a narrow bed.
Her hair was tangled.
Her dress was torn.
There was a bruise near her temple.
But her face—
Rosa's knees almost gave way.
It was Isabelle.
Exactly Isabelle.
The same green eyes.
The same small scar near her chin.
The same expression she had worn as a child when she was trying not to cry.
“Rosa?”
Rosa pressed her hand against the glass.
“I'm here.”
“Please open the door.”
Rosa looked for a lock.
There was a keypad beside the handle.
“Do you know the code?”
The girl shook her head.
“Grandfather gave me something.”
“What?”
She reached beneath her mattress and pulled out a small piece of paper.
She held it against the window.
A series of numbers.
Rosa entered them.
The keypad flashed red.
ACCESS DENIED.
She tried again.
Nothing.
“Rosa,” the girl whispered.
“Yes?”
“Did they find the body?”
Rosa froze.
“Yes.”
The girl closed her eyes.
“Good.”
Rosa stared at her.
“Good?”
The girl looked up.
“Then they think I'm dead.”
Rosa stepped closer.
“Why would you want them to think that?”
The girl began crying.
“Because if they know I'm alive, they'll come back for me.”
Rosa looked down at the letter in her hand.
The girl who fell tonight was not Isabelle.
She looked at the young woman behind the door.
“Who fell?”
The girl hesitated.
Then she whispered:
“My sister.”
Rosa felt the corridor tilt.
“Your sister?”
The girl nodded.
“We were born on the same day.”
Rosa looked at her face.
Identical.
Not similar.
Identical.
“Where is she now?”
The girl looked toward the ceiling.
“She's the one they buried.”
Rosa shook her head.