I’d had that thought before. I had grown surprisingly good at it.
It was Paul who had taught me how to file an exception without giving the recipient any reason to feel accused. Find the question the recipient knows how to answer, he told me. Ask that one first. I had followed the advice with great success through a timber inspection, a dispute about the location of a gas meter, and a neighborhood meeting where a man with a bicycle bell had rung it every time somebody used the phrase mixed use. It had helped me get good at my job. It had also helped me spend the winter asking everybody except Martin why Schedule C still hadn’t been circulated to the occupants.
On a damp Tuesday in February, I’d opened a copy of the occupancy table at Rita’s cutting counter. She set her pencil down on the fabric so it would stop rolling toward the floor.
“Read me the part about my rent.”
“It's a working copy. The rent restriction is in the agreement with the city. The schedule tells them who qualifies.”
“Who’s them?”
“The new owner and the city. Maybe the lender, but the lender won’t be making the decision.”
“Which of those people would I call?”
I didn’t have an answer she could use. I told her I would bring back the names. She lifted the pencil and drew a straight line on the cloth. She was about to cut out an entire sleeve by eye, and I remember wanting that kind of nerve.
“Your mother used to tell me when she didn’t know something,” she said.
“So do I.”
“You tell me when the paperwork doesn’t know. It’s a little different.”
That night I called my mother from the curb. She said Rita’s questions were a habit acquired because when she was young a landlord had refurbished a corner lot and bumped her rent by nearly half. The story had no spectacular ending. Rita packed everything up, three clients went somewhere else, and the family spent four months using the dining table as a work surface. If you tell people the dramatic parts of their own life are ordinary, my mother said, they may start expecting you to show up in the extraordinary parts. I asked her whether she thought I was talking down to Rita. She said she thought other people might be talking down to me. It was the lighter answer, and we both took it.
Later that week, I put the names of all twenty-three occupants into our schedule and drafted a note that linked each to the relevant records. Eleven qualified without any question. Five had minor paperwork gaps I could close with invoices and prior rent rolls. The other seven were acknowledged in the full occupancy file, but for various reasons our legal team wanted the city to review their records before anybody promised that they qualified. Rita fell into the last group because Artemont had included her later renewal in a separate building file, and because long before our company acquired the ground lease, she had taken over the shop from a cousin through a transfer nobody could find completely countersigned. She had twenty-six years of tax returns and a letter from the first owner congratulating her on taking the space, but an unsigned form in a folder was going to depend on the person opening it, so I gave the folder a bright yellow label with her name in large black type.
I thought of that file as I brought the printed packets into the conference room. Paul sat to my left. Priya Shah, who was lead counsel for Artemont on the closing and could remember no one’s birthday but everybody’s deadlines, opened a call with the title team on the monitor at the far end. Martin sat near the window with his jacket pulled back and a silver pen neatly parallel to the edge of his pad. We spent ten minutes reviewing what Priya called the run of show. Our signatures would collect in escrow. Northline would authorize the release. Priya would confirm with the city that the conditions had been met. In every one of our rehearsals, the city’s approval had sounded like pressing a switch. That morning there was a long blank where somebody ought to have said the city had accepted the occupant schedule. I mistook the blank for something agreed out of my hearing.
Then the glass door opened and Daine asked his question.
After he said he wanted to talk about the contract, nobody had the courage to take him literally. Martin stood without putting both hands on the table, a remarkable piece of discipline for a man I had seen use furniture to underscore punctuation.
“I apologize for the confusion downstairs,” he said. “We expected you to arrive with your attorneys.”
Daine glanced at the empty chair. “I asked for the office by name.”
“Absolutely. We had personnel coming in and out of the building. Certain people are expected to check in at a different entrance.”
“I checked in.”
“If any of our building staff reacted inappropriately, I’ll make sure it’s handled.”
“The security officer did what you told him to do.”
Martin’s hand went to the stem of his water glass. He hadn’t been expecting to hear that. His apology, I realized, had consisted of several doors he could close between himself and the event. Daine had come through each one.
Paul stood up as if to pull out the empty chair, then saw it was already pulled out. “Can we get you coffee?”
“I already had one.”
Daine put his canvas case on the table and sat. He set his phone screen down. I retreated to the end of the table I usually occupied and found the inside of my mouth dry. It seemed foolish to be afraid when the thing I’d done, by any useful definition, was fetch someone a coffee. But I’d heard Martin say “certain people,” and I thought of the twenty-three names I’d spent so long writing down.