âWill this do it?â she asked.
âIt helps with the dates. The older lease proves there was an arrangement. We could use the countersigned transfer.â
âHave you asked Sam?â
âSam who?â
âThe person who kept the box for Mr. Pritchett. I donât remember his last name. Arthur Pritchett leased the building before Artemont. The man had an office the size of a telephone booth across from the bakery. He kept the receipts and the letters and you never needed an appointment to go in there.â
I told her there was no tenant named Sam on the current or the old rolls Iâd seen. She laughed.
âHe wasnât a tenant. They used to give him a small paycheck from the rent. I heard Arthur sold his management company to somebody over by the post office. The papers probably stayed where they were. See what Rita remembers.â
She took the receipt out of the sleeve and laid it flat while I held my phone above it. Unlike the records produced by our file system, its type softened in the light. We had to move it twice to see the ink on the date. Before I put it back in the sleeve, I asked my mother how she had remembered which box to look in. She said she remembered the day because she and Rita had had a disagreement about whether the work was six dollars or eight. It was a plain new fact after so much formal language. I asked who had won.
âTechnically, me,â she said. âBut I spent the next twenty years buying her coffee, so youâd have to do the math.â
I went back to the Annex that afternoon. Rita remembered Sam as Sammy, and the tool library had an old referral from his property office with a number that went to a bakery wholesaler. We did find the name of the management company on a letter in a metal cashbox. The company still existed, with three current employees and one family member who occasionally answered the email address on its municipal registration. I called and left a message. Sam had retired. His niece answered the email an hour later and said her father had kept the lease jackets when they sold. They were in a storage room she planned to clean out that summer. If she could speak to Rita and confirm the right to release anything, sheâd look. She could make no promises about the pace. She ran a small distribution business from the same desk and had two people coming at five to pick up a set of shelves.
Rita called, then leaned in the doorway of her shop for a few minutes while I finished putting the occupancy-history notes in order. The floor was pocked where the first tenant, a furniture upholsterer, had hammered tacks into pieces of cardboard so they wouldnât get underfoot. Someone had wanted to grind the marks down in the nineties and tear out the radiator that sat crooked along one wall. When the work didnât proceed, Rita had set a line of small boxes between the radiator and the wall and used them to put away coat buttons. She had told herself the boxes were there for one summer. At their clean top edges you could see they had been picked up and put down again hundreds of times.
âHow will we get anybody to agree if they donât find it?â she said.
âAsk them to look at the records together. You had the lease in one name, then completion of a move-in and payments in your own. The company took your rent for years. The city can take evidence from both sides.â
âWell,â she said, her back still against the doorframe, âIâd like to see the sides.â
Looking down the corridor, I could see the tiny end of the office where the building manager had moved his desk to get out of the cold. I knew it would have to be unlocked on Monday for the visit. There was a spot near it on the concrete floor where three colors of renovation paint had made a chipped staircase of rectangles. The old office obviously belonged to a building somebody had been remaking for ninety years. The question was what the present owners were prepared to do for the people who would have to live with their choices. I thought Rita had put her finger on it. Before anybody could reasonably ask her to move that press, they would have to come in and stand across from her. A signature on a schedule could hide who had refused to do that. It couldnât answer her twice.
On Monday, Martin arrived at the Annex seven minutes early. I saw him through the front glass, pacing the sidewalk along the side of the building and looking up at the windows where a tenant had taped a sheet of plastic over a crack. He had changed out of his good gray suit and into the jacket he wore on site visits. It was olive green and had a shallow tear at the edge of the inside pocket. Heâd had it mended in dark thread someone had found that nearly matched. I knew who had mended it. A few years earlier, before anyone was going to sell the Annex, he had walked into Ritaâs shop and asked her where a man might get a jacket fixed around there. She had told him to take it off before she took it apart. He had done as he was told. I wondered whether he remembered.
When the others arrived, Helen asked if I was there as a tenant representative. I said Rita had asked me to come because I knew the history of the unit files. We had already agreed I would talk about what I had seen and done, and that nobody would put company documents in my hands that morning. Helen wrote âoccupant supportâ on her attendance sheet. She gave me a pen. I signed on the same line, below the name of a man who was there to show people how to open a broken gate without scraping the skin off their knuckles.