The morning wore on, and the light in the office changed, and Rebecca finished her first reading of the papers and set them in a neat stack. She told Margaret that she had done well to refuse, that she had done well to bring the papers, and that she had done well to tell the story in full, even the hard facts about supper and the pantry and the telephone. She told Margaret to sign nothing, to keep a record of each new rule and each new demand, and to call Rebecca at once if Jessica set new papers before her or if Grant pressed her to sign. Margaret promised to keep a record, and she promised to call, and she got up from her chair with a steadiness she had not shown when she arrived. Rebecca walked her to the door, and she watched Margaret go down the stairs with the cloth bag now empty, and she returned to her desk with the papers spread before her, knowing that the reading had only begun, and that the house in Oak Park held more to learn.
Margaret Cole returned to the office of Rebecca Shaw on a morning when rain had washed the street outside and the light through the window looked pale and thin. She carried no bag this time, and she carried no papers, because the papers stayed in the folder on Rebecca desk, safe from the house in Oak Park. She had come to report what had happened in the house since the morning she had first brought the papers, and to tell Rebecca, in order, how the three months of rules had narrowed her life, day by day, until the house she had owned since nineteen eighty nine felt smaller than the rooms within it. Rebecca greeted her at the door, she guided her to the same chair, she closed the door, and she set a fresh sheet of paper on the desk, ready to write down each rule as Margaret named it.
Margaret began with the sitting room, because the sitting room had been the first room to change. Jessica Cole had told her where she might sit, and where she might not sit, and the chair by the window, the chair Margaret had favoured for years, had been claimed for Jessica use, and Margaret had been told to sit in a chair near the door, where the light was poor and the draught from the hall reached her shoulders. Margaret had obeyed at first, telling herself that a chair was only a chair, and that peace in the house mattered more than a place by the window. But the rule had stayed, and the chair by the window had stayed empty when Jessica was out, and Margaret had learned to sit near the door even when the house stood quiet and no one else was in the room. Rebecca wrote down the rule about the chair, and she asked Margaret if the rule had been spoken aloud or had simply grown into place, and Margaret said that Jessica had spoken it once, in a clear voice, and had never needed to speak it again.
The rules about food had followed the rules about sitting, and they had grown tighter with each week. Margaret told Rebecca that Jessica decided when Margaret might eat, and that supper had become a meal taken at a set hour, and that the kitchen had been closed after the meal, so that a late arrival meant no supper at all. Breakfast had grown thin, and lunch had grown uncertain, and Margaret had learned to keep bread and fruit in her room, hidden in a drawer, so that she would not go hungry when the kitchen stood locked. The pantry had been locked two days after Margaret refused the papers, and the key had been kept by Jessica, and Margaret had needed to ask for sugar and tea and flour as if she were asking a favour from a stranger. Rebecca wrote down the pantry rule, and she wrote down the dinner ban, and she saw how the two rules worked together, one closing the table and the other closing the store of food.
The telephone had been taken from its usual place on the hall table, Margaret said, and it had been moved to a shelf in the kitchen, where Jessica could hear every call. Margaret had once used the telephone freely, calling Daniel Cole in Seattle, calling friends in Oak Park, calling Rebecca when she needed advice, but now each call had to be made in the open, with Jessica near, and Margaret had learned to speak in short sentences, to give no detail, and to end the call quickly. Daniel called from Seattle, three thousand miles away, and his calls had grown short, and his voice had sounded tired, and Margaret had not told him about the rules, because Jessica stood near the telephone when he called, and because Margaret had not wished to worry a son who was already far from home and already under strain from a trip Grant Mercer had arranged. Rebecca asked if Margaret had tried to call Daniel when Jessica was out, and Margaret said that Jessica was seldom out, and that Grant visited often, and that the house seldom stood empty long enough for a private call.
Mail had been hidden, Margaret told Rebecca, and the hiding of mail had frightened her more than the locking of the pantry, because mail carried news of the world beyond the house, and its absence left Margaret unsure what was true. Mail addressed to Margaret had arrived at the house, and Jessica had taken it from the hall table, and Margaret had found them later, opened or set aside, or had not found them at all. She had asked Jessica about a bank statement that had not arrived, and Jessica had said that the mail had been slow, and that Margaret must have imagined the statement. She had asked about a note from Mrs. Patterson, the neighbour, and Jessica had said that no note had come, though Mrs. Patterson had later asked Margaret why she had not answered. Rebecca wrote down the mail rule, and she asked Margaret to remember each piece of mail that had gone missing, and Margaret promised to try, though the list was long and the dates had blurred in her mind.
Mrs. Patterson had been the first neighbour to notice a change, Margaret said, and the change in Mrs. Patterson manner had hurt Margaret in a way the locked pantry had not. Mrs. Patterson had once stopped at the gate for a long talk, sharing news of the street and asking after Daniel and Robert memory, but now she stopped only for a moment, and she spoke in a careful voice, and she looked at Margaret as if Margaret might forget the talk before the gate had closed behind her. Jessica had told the neighbours that Margaret was confused, and the talk had spread along the street, and Margaret had heard it in the way shopkeepers spoke to her, slowly and loudly, and in the way a neighbour had offered to help her cross a street she had crossed alone for decades. Rebecca listened, and she wrote down the words about confusion, because a story told to neighbours could do work that a locked door could not do, turning friends into watchers and turning a clear mind into a question in the minds of others.
The memory assessment had been booked for Friday, Margaret said, and the news had come without warning, in a voice that made it sound like a kindness. Jessica had told Margaret that a doctor would visit the house on Friday morning, and that the doctor would ask questions, and that Margaret should answer honestly, and that the visit was for her own good. Margaret had asked who had booked the visit, and Jessica had said that the family had agreed, though Daniel was in Seattle and had not been asked, and Margaret had not been asked either, until the visit was already set. Margaret had asked what the doctor would ask, and Jessica had said that the doctor would ask about memory and dates and names, and that Margaret should not worry, though the warning not to worry had made Margaret worry more. Rebecca wrote down the word Friday, and she wrote down the hour Jessica had named, and she told Margaret that she would be present in spirit if not in person, and that Margaret should answer only what was asked, and should say nothing about the papers until Rebecca advised her.
Margaret told Rebecca that the three months had felt like a slow closing of doors, one door at a time, until the house held fewer rooms for her than it had held before. She had been told where to sit, when to eat, what to touch, and what not to touch, and the rooms she had once moved through freely had grown full of rules she had not made. The kitchen had become a room to enter only at set hours, the sitting room had become a room where her chair stood near the door, the hall had become a place where mail vanished, and her own bedroom had become the only room where she could eat bread in peace. She had lived in the house since nineteen eighty nine, since the year she and Robert Cole had bought it with hope and a loan and a plan for a family, and now she felt like a guest who had stayed too long, a guest who must ask for food and for a chair and for the use of a telephone that had once been hers.
Rebecca asked Margaret about Grant Mercer, and Margaret said that Grant had been in the house often during the three months, talking with Jessica in low voices, and that the talk stopped when Margaret entered the room, and that Grant looked at Margaret with a politeness that left her cold. He had spoken of California as a place where Jessica might live a better life, and he had spoken of Seattle as a place where Daniel might learn new ways, and he had never asked Margaret what she wished for the future, as if her wishes no longer counted in the house she owned. Rebecca asked if Grant had ever given Margaret a paper to sign, and Margaret said that he had not, and that Jessica had been the one to set papers before her, but that Grant had looked at the papers with a familiarity that told Margaret he knew their contents well. Rebecca wrote down the visits, and she wrote down the talk of California, and she saw the shape of a plan that used distance and rules to wear down a woman who held fifty two percent of the voting shares of Cole Home Supply.