His case had been built around bank records, authorization forms, electronic signatures, and testimony from Victoria.
He had believed the evidence was overwhelming.
Now, the courtroom monitor had shown Victoria accessing David's office, entering the financial portal, and authorizing transactions.
And an audio recording had captured a conversation about deliberately making David responsible for the missing money.
Gaines turned toward the judge.
"Your Honor, the prosecution requests that the court suspend the proceedings pending a review of the newly introduced evidence."
Judge Foster looked at him.
"Mr. Gaines, I agree that the material requires examination. But I will not allow either party to characterize it before its authenticity has been established."
He turned toward Emily.
"Miss Williams, you indicated that there is another video."
Emily nodded.
"Yes, Your Honor."
"Can you explain what it depicts?"
Emily glanced at her father.
David was still standing beside her.
His attorney, Marcus Bell, had one hand resting on David's shoulder.
Emily took a breath.
"The first video shows Victoria transferring money from the foundation's accounts. The second shows what happened after she left the office."
"After she left?"
"Yes."
Judge Foster looked toward the technician.
"Is the file accessible?"
The technician nodded.
"I've located it, Your Honor. The file appears to be intact, although we have not yet verified the source."
"Proceed."
The monitor remained black for several seconds.
Then a security-camera image appeared.
The timestamp read:
MARCH 18 β 11:58 P.M.
The same office.
The same hallway.
The same camera angle.
Victoria appeared on screen, leaving David's office with a folder tucked beneath her arm.
She looked over her shoulder.
Then she walked toward the elevators.
The hallway remained empty.
For almost two minutes.
Then another figure appeared.
A man wearing a dark coat.
His face was partially obscured by the camera's poor resolution.
He walked directly toward David's office.
He didn't knock.
He opened the door.
He entered.
The courtroom became silent.
The technician zoomed in.
The man removed his coat.
He placed a briefcase on David's desk.
Then he opened the drawer.
He removed several documents.
He sat down.
And he began typing.
Emily stood motionless.
David leaned toward the screen.
"Who is that?"
Emily whispered.
"Thomas Reed."
The technician adjusted the image.
The man's face became clearer.
It was Thomas.
The former financial consultant.
The man who had supposedly resigned and moved away.
The man whose name had appeared in the audio recording.
Thomas opened a file on the computer.
He accessed the foundation's accounting system.
Then he began transferring money.
Not from one account.
From several.
The first transfer was $38,000.
The second was $72,000.
The third was $110,000.
He paused.
He checked the hallway.
Then he opened a drawer and removed a stack of documents.
The camera captured him placing them inside a folder.
The folder had David's name printed on it.
Thomas looked directly toward the camera.
For one brief second, his face was visible.
He smiled.
Then he closed the folder.
The video ended.
Nobody spoke.
Emily's eyes filled with tears.
David stared at the screen.
His hands were shaking.
"That's him."
Marcus Bell leaned toward him.
"David, don't say anything yet."
But David couldn't stop looking.
He remembered Thomas.
He remembered the man who had sat in his office for years.
The man who had helped establish the foundation's financial systems.
The man who had attended charity dinners.
The man who had once stood beside him at a hospital fundraiser and promised that every dollar would reach the people who needed it.
David remembered introducing Thomas to Emily.
He remembered Thomas telling her she should study finance because she was intelligent and observant.
He remembered laughing.
He remembered trusting him.
And now he was watching Thomas use his office to steal money.
To forge records.
To destroy his reputation.
David's voice was almost inaudible.
"He was in my office."
Marcus nodded.
"Yes."
"He was in my office, and I didn't know."
Emily turned toward her father.
"Dad..."
David shook his head.
"I trusted him."
His eyes filled.
"I trusted him."
Emily grabbed his hand.
"I'm sorry."
He looked at her.
"You don't have to apologize for this."
"But I believed them."
David swallowed.
"You were scared."
"I thought you might have done it."
He looked away.
For a moment, neither spoke.
Then David squeezed her hand.
"We'll talk about that later."
Emily nodded.
But she knew there was no escaping that conversation.
Not anymore.
Chapter 9 β The Prosecution's Last Attempt
Assistant District Attorney Robert Gaines stood again.
"Your Honor, the prosecution has serious concerns about the evidence presented."
Judge Foster looked at him.
"Specify your concerns."
"First, we have no established chain of custody. Second, the files may have been manipulated. Third, the recordings contain statements that may be misleading without context."
Emily's face tightened.
"Nothing was manipulated."
Marcus Bell gently touched her arm.
"Let the attorney speak."
Gaines continued.
"The defendant's daughter has had access to the foundation's offices. She may have obtained these materials through unauthorized means. We cannot establish who created the files or whether the timestamps are accurate."
Judge Foster nodded.
"Those are legitimate questions."
Gaines looked toward David.
"Additionally, the evidence presented does not establish that the defendant had no knowledge of the transactions. It merely shows other individuals accessing the system."
David's attorney stood.
"Your Honor, the prosecution's own witness testified that Mr. Williams personally approved the transfers. The newly presented video demonstrates that those approvals may have been fabricated."
Gaines replied:
"The footage does not prove that every transaction was unauthorized."
Marcus Bell opened a folder.
"Then let's examine them individually."
He placed several documents on the table.
"These are the original bank records obtained by our office. The transaction dates correspond to the video footage. The account access logs indicate that Mr. Williams was not present when several transfers were authorized."
Gaines looked at the documents.
His expression changed.
Marcus continued.
"Mr. Williams was attending a charity conference in Denver during three of the transfers. He was hospitalized for a minor cardiac procedure during another. And on the night shown in the video, he was at home with his daughter."
Emily looked toward her father.
David nodded slowly.
"Yes."
Marcus turned toward the judge.
"We have the hospital records, hotel records, and witness statements."
Judge Foster examined the documents.
"Mr. Gaines?"