Even if she got behind the portrait, Marco had said the inner steel door held a second lock—and Matteo wore that tiny slotted watch key strapped directly against his ribs.
Clara turned back toward the desk, scanning the blotter and the side drawers with desperate speed. She pulled the middle drawer half an inch; it slid cleanly without locking, revealing neatly stacked blank stationery, sealing wax, and a slim silver letter opener. No watch. No spare key. Of course not—a man like Matteo Bellini didn't leave spare vault keys lying beside envelopes.
She pushed the drawer quietly shut and moved toward the leather valet stand tucked beside the fireplace, where a spare black suit coat hung neatly on cedar shoulders. She checked the breast pocket gently with two fingertips—nothing but a clean white linen handkerchief folded crisp as cardboard.
A sharp metallic clink echoed from the gravel driveway outside the tall leaded window.
Clara froze mid-breath, stepping smoothly back away from the valet stand toward the fireplace broom as headlights swept diagonally across the rain-streaked glass, throwing long silver bars across the dark walls. Not one car—two black SUVs crunching fast up the drive, far earlier than Matteo had told Mrs. Greer he would return from New Jersey.
Voices erupted sharply near the front portico—Gabe barking an order that cut off mid-syllable, followed by the heavy slam of a car door and quick, uneven footsteps crossing the foyer marble toward the rear wing.
Clara didn't have time to slip out through the service corridor without walking straight past the foyer arch. Her eyes darted wildly around the dark oak study—toward the curtained window embrasure, toward the closet door beside the bookshelves. Before she could move three paces, the heavy brass handle turned from the outside, and the mahogany door swung violently inward.
Matteo stumbled half a step across the threshold before catching himself cleanly against the doorjamb with his right hand. His left arm hung clamped tightly over his ribcage, and beneath the unbuttoned wool of his wet black coat, a dark stain glossy as fresh tar spread down the left side of his black cotton shirt.
Gabe hurried right behind him, wet rain dripping off his silver hair, one hand hovering near Matteo's elbow without daring to actually grab the Don's arm. "Boss, let me call Dr. Messina up from White Plains. You caught that edge clean through the fascia—"
"No doctor," Matteo clipped out between teeth clenched white, every syllable tight with fury and cold pain. He halted dead three feet into the room, his eyes snapping straight to Clara standing motionless beside the hearth with the empty linen stack still resting against her forearm.
For two lethal seconds, nobody breathed. Rain hammered the leaded panes behind Matteo's rain-darkened shoulders.
"What are you doing in here?" Matteo asked, his voice dropping low and lethal despite the blood soaking visibly through his waistcoat onto the dark wool of his trousers.
Clara didn't glance toward the portrait or the desk. She kept her voice steady, dropping the folded napkins gently onto the edge of the leather armchair before stepping smoothly forward. "Mrs. Greer left the laundry cart down the hall and asked me to check if the fireplace grate needed clearing before tonight's storm. You're bleeding, Mr. Bellini."
"Leave us, Gabe," Matteo muttered, swaying fractionally as he forced himself upright off the doorjamb and walked stiffly toward the green leather sofa beneath the side bookshelves. "Check the front gates. Tell Tony to sweep the south perimeter wall again. Nobody else comes up the drive tonight."
"Boss—"
"Out, Gabe. Lock the foyer doors behind you."
Gabe hesitated one beat, shooting Clara a sharp, dark warning glance from beneath bushy eyebrows before backing out and pulling the heavy door shut with a solid click.
Matteo dropped heavily onto the leather cushions, letting out one sharp, ragged exhale through his nose as his head tipped back briefly against the wood paneling. Rain ran in cold silver tracks down his cheekbone into the black collar of his shirt. When he opened his eyes again, they locked directly onto Clara standing five feet away.
"Can you stitch skin, or do you faint when shirts come off?" he demanded softly, biting off the sarcasm before it turned ugly.
"Before my sister got hurt, I worked two years as a surgical prep aide at Lawrence Hospital," Clara answered quietly, moving without asking across the room to the small wet bar built inside the bookshelf cabinet. She found a sealed bottle of clear vodka, grabbed two clean bar towels from the lower shelf, and knelt beside the leather sofa just as she had knelt before his son in the ballroom. "Take your coat off before it ruins the wool, and tell me if it went through or grazed."
Matteo stared down at the crown of her copper hair bent cleanly beneath the green banker's lamp. Then, slowly, wincing barely enough to tighten the corner of his mouth, he shrugged his right shoulder free of the soaked coat and let Clara ease the left sleeve gently down his bruised arm.
"Grazed," he muttered as she unbuttoned his black waistcoat one steady button at a time, peeling back the soaked fabric from the broad ribs beneath. "Two idiots on bikes waiting outside the Bayonne toll plaza. Thought a rainy evening meant slow reaction time."
Clara carefully unbuttoned the wet cotton shirt down to his waist, biting the inside of her lip to steady her hands. Beneath his dark chest hair, along the lower sweep of his left ribs, an ugly three-inch furrow had torn cleanly through skin and muscle, weeping bright red down toward his silver belt buckle. Not deep enough to hit lung, thank God, though wide enough to soak a coat in ten minutes without compression. Alongside the fresh wound, high on his left shoulder, sat an older puckered bullet scar pale against his olive skin.