I walked slowly past the rear bumper of his pickup, letting the rain run cold across my collar, until I stood four feet from him inside the dry shadow of the open barn doorway. The smell of fresh-sawn old wood, turpentine, and cedar oil hung thick in the chill air.
"Funny," I said quietly. "I saw you coming out of my cellar bulkhead at six-forty this morning, Martin. Slipping a brass slide-bolt into your pocket."
Martin blinked hard, his jaw working. "Old latch on the bottom bulkhead frame rusted clear through. I pulled it to match the screw pattern at the hardware store—"
"Take off the coat," I said, my voice flat.
He stared at me, bewildered. "What?"
"Your navy coat. And pull back that tarp."
A flush of dark red crept up Martin's thick neck. He stepped sideways, instinctively putting his body between me and the bed of his pickup. "Garrett, hold on now. You're wound tighter than a drum—"
"I've got a dead wife, Martin!" The words cracked out of me harder than I meant them to, echoing up into the dark timber rafters. "Her watch broke on my cellar steps at eight-fourteen PM—sixteen minutes before the power went out. Somebody bolted that door from the outside. My seven-year-old daughter hasn't spoken a word in fourteen months because she saw a man in a dark blue sleeve standing at the top of those stairs!"
Martin stopped dead.
The defensive flush drained straight out of his face, leaving him gray and stunned in the dim barn light. His thick hands dropped away from the tailgate as if the metal had turned scalding hot.
"Wait," he breathed, staring at me with wide, horrified eyes. "You think—God in heaven, Garrett, you think I hurt Claire?"
"Tell me what's under the tarp, Martin! Tell me why your coat smells like the cellar and why you're sneaking around behind the windbreak!"
I stepped past him and yanked the wet olive canvas straight off the pickup bed.
There were no tools wrapped in blood. No missing trust folders. No secret boxes from my cellar.
Stacked neatly on moving blankets across the truck bed were twelve wide, honey-dark antique floorboards—hand-planed American chestnut, nearly two inches thick and twelve feet long, worth a small fortune to restoration architects.
I stared at the lumber, my pulse hammering uselessly against my ribs. Slowly, I turned back to Martin.
He looked like a man who had just aged ten years in five seconds. His broad shoulders slumped completely, his rough hands dropping to his sides as he leaned back against the barn door frame.